Probability and informed consent

Probability and informed consent
Book Chapter
Nir Ben-Moshe, Benjamin A. Levinstein, Jonathan Livengood
Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics, 8 August 2023 [Springer]
Abstract
In this paper, we illustrate some serious difficulties involved in conveying information about uncertain risks and securing informed consent for risky interventions in a clinical setting. We argue that in order to secure informed consent for a medical intervention, physicians often need to do more than report a bare, numerical probability value. When probabilities are given, securing informed consent generally requires communicating how probability expressions are to be interpreted and communicating something about the quality and quantity of the evidence for the probabilities reported. Patients may also require guidance on how probability claims may or may not be relevant to their decisions, and physicians should be ready to help patients understand these issues.