Informed Consent Practices Among Emergency Staff for Patients Undergoing Emergency Surgery in the Emergency Surgical Units of Two Tertiary Teaching Hospitals in Uganda: A Qualitative Study

Informed Consent Practices Among Emergency Staff for Patients Undergoing Emergency Surgery in the Emergency Surgical Units of Two Tertiary Teaching Hospitals in Uganda: A Qualitative Study
Research Article
Olivia Kituuka, Ian Munabi, Moses Galukande, Adelline Twimukye, Erisa Mwaka
BMC Medical Ethics, 25 June 2024
Abstract
Background
Staff in low resourced emergency units of a low-income country face the challenge of obtaining informed consent for incapacitated patients or their next of kin in a time-constrained situation often in an overcrowded environment. Therefore, we aimed to establish the informed consent practices for emergency surgical care among healthcare professional at two emergency surgical units at two tertiary teaching hospitals in Uganda.
Methods
In October 2022 – February 2023we conducted key informant interviews in Uganda and purposively selected 16 staff in surgical emergency units at two tertiary teaching hospitals and directly observed the informed consent practices. Data was managed and analyzed inductively using NVivo version 12.
Results
Six themes emerged from key informant interviews including knowledge and perspectives no informed consent; processes, procedures, and practices regarding informed consent; communication strategies for informed consent; ethical considerations; benefits of informed consent during surgery; and challenges to emergency informed consent. Staff had adequate knowledge about informed consent but faced several challenges during the consent process due to lack of guiding institutional policies. Overall, the informed consent process was inadequate at both institutions with greeting of patients, disclosure of risks and assessment of understanding poorly done. Consent was conducted in a noisy environment at both institutions and there was no privacy in the public hospital.
Conclusion
Although knowledge about consent practices by emergency staff at both institutions was good, in practice there was inadequate disclosure of risks, inadequate knowledge about the surgical procedure, risks, and benefits. Emergency staff identified the need for procedure specific consent documents which capture the information that is given to the patient and guiding policies on consent for incapacitated patients who have no surrogates.